| Season | Player | Position | Team | Year |
| 1965 | Randy Schmidt | 1B | 2nd | SR |
| Jim Alviso | P | 2nd | JR | |
| 1966 | Ron Parkinson | 3B | 2nd | JR |
| Jim Alviso | P | 2nd | SR | |
| 1967 | Jim Scales | C | 2nd | SR |
| 1968 | Bobby Heal | 2B | 2nd | |
| Kevin White | C | 2nd | JR | |
| Larry Page | P | 2nd | ||
| 1969 | None | |||
| 1970 | Mike Shelton | 1B | 2nd | SR |
| Tom Devaney | 2B | 2nd | JR | |
| 1971 | Tom Devaney | P | 1st | SR |
| Gene Jamison | C | 2nd | SR | |
| Robin Green | IF | 2nd | SR | |
| 1972 | Dan Duke | P | 1st | SR |
| Al Scmidt | IF | 2nd | SR | |
| 1973 | Dan McDonald | IF | 2nd | |
| 1974 | Mark Lehman | IF | 2nd | |
| Dave Spencer | IF | 2nd | JR | |
| Bob Stoddard | P | 2nd | JR | |
| 1975 | Ken Stayton | OF | 1st | |
| Dave O'Brian | OF | 1st | ||
| Steve Stone | Utility | 1st | JR | |
| Bob Stoddard | P | 2nd | SR | |
| Tim Duke | 1B | 2nd | ||
| Dave Spencer | IF | 2nd | SR | |
| 1976 | Vance Rushing | IF | 1st | JR |
| Steve Stone | P | 2nd | SR | |
| Tim Shatswell | Utility | 2nd | JR | |
| 1977 | Mark Davis | P | 1st | JR |
| Vance Rushing | IF | 1st | SR | |
| Tim Shatswell | C | 2nd | SR | |
| 1978 | Mark Davis | P | 1st | SR |
| Wes Karch | IF | 1st | ||
| Steve Stoddard | C | 2nd | ||
| 1979 | Jeff Hoffman | Utility | 2nd | |
| Carl Dice | IF | 2nd | JR | |
| 1980 | Brian Swalles | P | 1st | |
| Jeff Hoffman | C | 2nd | ||
| Carl Dice | IF | 2nd | SR | |
| Cory Cruz | OF | 2nd | ||
| 1981 | Ben Breazeale | IF | 1st | |
| Scott Common | OF | 1st | ||
| Kevin Trudeau | P | 2nd | JR | |
| Bob Peterson | OF | 2nd | JR | |
| 1982 | Kevin Trudeau | P | 2nd | SR |
| Jeff Reilly | IF | 2nd | ||
| Bob Peterson | OF | 2nd | SR | |
| 1983 | Charlie White | C | 1st | |
| Steve Senft | OF | 1st | ||
| Robert Darylample | Utility | 2nd | ||
| Ben Mongerson | DH | 2nd | ||
| 1984 | Jeff March | P | 2nd | |
| Tony Debok | OF | 2nd | ||
| 1985 | Tim Hubbs | 1B | 1st | |
| Raul Soria | IF | 1st | ||
| Louie Aguiar | P | 2nd | ||
| Dave Phillips | IF | 2nd | ||
| 1986 | Darin Davis | IF | 1st | |
| Vince Farfan | OF | 1st | JR | |
| Jim Mathis | Utility | 1st | JR | |
| Shiloh Roten | 1B | 2nd | ||
| Russ Bearows | OF | 2nd | ||
| 1987 | Jim Mathis | Utility | 1st | SR |
| Jim Perkins | IF | 2nd | ||
| Vince Farfan | OF | 2nd | SR | |
| 1988 | Gary March | P | 1st | SR |
| Paul Alcott | IF | 2nd | ||
| Junior Farfan | Utility | 2nd | ||
| 1989 | Junior Farfan | C | 1st | SR |
| Matt McCormick | IF | 1st | JR | |
| Jason Alviso | IF | 2nd | SR | |
| 1990 | Matt McCormick | IF | 1st | SR |
| Shorty Farfan | Utility | 1st | SO | |
| Wade Diebner | IF | 2nd | JR | |
| 1991 | John Brown | OF | 1st | |
| Shorty Farfan | P | 2nd | JR | |
| Wade Diebner | IF | 2nd | SR | |
| 1992 | Shorty Farfan | P | 1st | SR |
| Dan Cariss | 1B | 1st | SR | |
| Tim Bailey | IF | 1st | ||
| Brian Sexson | OF | 2nd | SR | |
| 1993 | Carlos Arrellano | OF | 1st | SR |
| Jerome Alviso | Utility | 1st | SR | |
| Jason Sekany | P | 2nd | SR | |
| 1994 | Matt Luckett | IF | 2nd | JR |
| Tanner Dayak | OF | 2nd | JR | |
| 1995 | Matt Luckett | IF | 1st | SR |
| Ryan Abramsom | IF | 1st | JR | |
| Nate Schmidt | IF | 2nd | SR | |
| Richard Torres | Utility | 2nd | JR | |
| Dustin Wortham | DH | 2nd | JR | |
| 1996 | Brian Candelario | OF | 1st | SR |
| Richard Torres | OF | 1st | SR | |
| Pat Twiss | IF | 1st | SO | |
| Corrigan Willis | Utility | 1st | SR | |
| Ryan Abramson | IF | 2nd | SR | |
| 1997 | Adam Stephens | OF | 1st | SO |
| Tim Conrad | IF | 2nd | JR | |
| Pat Twiss | IF | 2nd | JR | |
| Kenon Willis | P | 2nd | JR | |
| 1998 | Adam Stephens | OF | 1st | JR |
| Pat Twiss | IF | 1st | SR | |
| Joe Pulluzzi | OF | 1st | SR | |
| Kenon Willis | P | 2nd | SR | |
| Brett Abramson | C | 2nd | SR | |
| Mike Beck | DH | 2nd | JR | |
| 1999-2007 | Missing Records | |||
| 2008 | Drew Helenihi | OF | 1st | SR |
| Ino Patron | DH | 1st | SO | |
| 2009 | Kyle Kearney | OF | 1st | JR |
| Blake Bonde | P | 2nd | SR | |
| Garry Lenhardt | C | 2nd | SR | |
| Tim McGarvey | IF | 2nd | SR | |
| 2010 | Ino Patron | 1B | 1st | SR |
| John Love | P | 2nd | SR | |
| 2011 | Justin Fogle | IF | 1st | SR |
| Rett Cortez | Utility | 1st | SR | |
| Ryan Kirby | 1B | 1st | SO | |
| Vince Fernandez | OF | 1st | SO | |
| Marcus Mastrobuoni | C | 2nd | SR | |
| 2012 | Jordan Thrailkill | DH | 1st | JR |
| Casey Soltis | OF | 1st | SO | |
| Chris Wilson | C | 1st | SR | |
| Dan Whitney | IF | 2nd | JR | |
| 2013 | Jacob Payne | P | MVP-Pitcher | SR |
| Anthony Olmo | P | 1st | SR | |
| Dan Whitney | IF | 1st | SR | |
| Matt Richards | DH | 1st | SR | |
| Vince Fernandez | OF | 1st | SR | |
| Ryan Kirby | OF | 2nd | SR | |
| Jordan Thrailkill | C | 2nd | SR | |
| 2014 | Casey Soltis | OF | League MVP | SR |
| Matty Proetel | DH | 1st | SR | |
| 2015 | Alex Cupps | IF | 2nd | SR |
| 2016 | Zac Heinz | P | 2nd | JR |
| CJ Malski | IF | 2nd | JR | |
| 2017 | AJ McMillan | Utility | 2nd | SR |
| Tyler Stultz | P | 2nd | SR | |
| 2018 | Jake Crittenden | C | 2nd | SR |
| 2019 | Gavin Napier | IF | 2nd | JR |
| 2020 | NO LEAGUE SEASON | COVID-19 | PANDEMIC | |
